What does a cash-positive month actually tell you?
Consider an invented self-service laundromat. One paid wash cycle is the unit. We compare monthly operating cash, simple payback and discounted value using the public Planner's fictional inputs.
FICTIONAL EXAMPLE · ALL INPUTS INVENTED · NO CUSTOMER OR MARKET DATA
Cash and value: cycles × $3 − $6,000 = monthly operating cash; simple payback = $100,000 ÷ positive monthly cash. NPV = −$100,000 + Σ(12 × monthly cash ÷ 1.10year) for years 1–10, with cash at each year end.
Three sales cases, same costs
Lower sales
2,400 cycles / month
Monthly operating cash
$1,200.00
Simple payback
83.3 months
10-year NPV
−$11,518.23
Base sales
3,000 cycles / month
Monthly operating cash
$3,000.00
Simple payback
33.3 months
10-year NPV
$121,204.42
Higher sales
3,600 cycles / month
Monthly operating cash
$4,800.00
Simple payback
20.8 months
10-year NPV
$253,927.07
Read both measures. Lower sales still produces positive monthly operating cash, yet its 10-year NPV is negative. Simple payback ignores discounting, so a payback inside the ten-year window does not make NPV positive.